Ethical issues of genetic enhancement in humans philosophy essay

Ethics of genetic engineering

Question 1. In this hypothetical scenario, would it be morally wrong to use this technology not only as a means of treatment, but also to promote the enhancement of healthy individuals? Resnik, D. I put forward two arguments for the morality of genetic human enhancement. Steroids and growth hormone improve muscle strength. Dijstelbloem, and D. The context of the ethical debate changes further when considering, say, the enhancement of military personnel, where gaining an advantage over the opposition is less of an ethical matter and more of a strategic necessity.

To put it another way, any person who values life will value its continuation and the pursuit of means that are likely to promote this possibility. This type of determinism, which we shall call psychological determinism, has some profound implications for morality and the law, since we normally ascribe moral or legal responsibility to people under the assumption that they can choose freely.

Two further meetings were held in Washington, and one in Paris. For example, a person who is born with two copies of the Sickle Cell allele will almost certainly develop Sickle Cell Disease SCDprovided that some necessary environmental conditions obtain.

Ethical issues of genetic enhancement in humans philosophy essay

A dancer may need physiotherapy to treat an injury arising from their profession, or a student may need cognitive enhancers to address anxiety caused by the prospect of difficult exams. The beauty industry is testimony to the attraction of enhancement. London: Fourth Estate. In sport, human erythropoietin boosts red blood cells. Most people implicitly reject this view -we screen embryos and fetuses for diseases, even mild correctible diseases. We must remember that nature alots advantage and disadvantage with no gesture to fairness. Question 1. Each of these areas approach the significance of human enhancement from quite different perspectives. Indeed, while it is possible that increasing height or speed could yield benefits for the individual concerned, in a society where all people undertake similar enhancements, then the overall benefit is nullified. Furthermore, it is necessary to clarify the relationship between moral and ethical, as they are often conflated within debates about human enhancement. Many authors, though, have already addressed these objections over the last years Agar ; Glover ; Bostrom and Ord ; Harris ; Blackford , He argues that what distinguishes liberal eugenics from the objectionable eugenic practices of the Nazis is that it is not based on a single conception of a desirable genome and that it is voluntary and not obligatory. We will call this the Open Future Critique. With the preceding comments in mind, we now consider genetic determinism. In some cases, the despotism may be mild and benevolent.

The essential caveat to the paper is that Liao does not endorse any of these hypotheticals. Yet, questions remain about how far society is prepared to accept these kinds of applications and what ethical issues they create.

Indeed, these examples are also characterised by a lack of consensus about their value. Leaving aside any discussion of genetic causation and assuming that, in this case, the gene strongly determines the phenotype cancerscience might yet discover a pre-emptive cure for that particular cancer and thus prevent phenotypic expression.

I want to argue that far from being merely permissible, we have a moral obligation or moral reason to enhance ourselves and our children.

Listening to Prozac. The Neglectful parents give birth to a child with a special condition. According to Lewontin[ 34 ], genetic fatalism also has social and political implications, because it implies that much of social and political realities are beyond our control.

why genetic enhancement is good

Kramer, P. The aim of UGM is then to maximise the number of genes being passed on to the next generation during the reproductive years without careful selection for what genes might be desirable for post-reproductive life. Why not enhancement?

Rated 10/10 based on 67 review
Ethics Issues Raised by Human Enhancement